Notes on Lawers

 

The earliest documentary evidence of the McDougalls comes from a record in the Kenmore Old Parish Register showing Hugh McDougall’s marriage to Mary Ferguson in 1775 at Borland Farm in Fernan, near Fortingall.  Around 1812, the family moved west along the loch to Lawers and took up a tenancy in the township of Cuiltrannich.

 

Cuiltrannich, meaning nook of bracken in Gaelic, was part of the Breadalbane lands. In 1770 it was registered to Colonel Robertson of Lawers, for an annual rental of £305.

The exact extents of Cuiltrannich are unknown, but the cultivated area appears to have covered at least 45 acres of ground on the lower slopes of Ben Lawers, just west of the Lawers Burn ravine.   The surveyors working for the Farquarson Survey of 1769 observed that, "…the bank on both sides of the [Lawers] burn is so steep and dangerous especially near the head of the farms as frequently to occasion the death of some of their cattle.  On this account both sides of the burn, where danger is, ought to be enclosed and planted with firs or oaks." *

 

At the time of the Survey, there were 3 smallholdings. 2 more were constructed later, further up the hill, and may have been allocated to the soldiers known as the Breadalbane Fencibles who returned from duty in Europe in 1797. One of the lower farmhouses remained unchanged, and was occupied, well into the 20th century **. Its ruins, and some others, are still visible, along with a prominent, sunken access track.

 

The township had a smithy, a school, a lime kiln and a meal mill. It also possessed the only lint mill on the north side of Loch Tay. This was located beside the Lawers Burn below the Killin to Kenmore road, close to the loch. It was used to process flax into linen.

 

*   Plans and Book of reference relating to survey of the north side of Lochtay by John Farquharson, 1769
** Rural settlement in the Scottish Highlands, 1750-1850: A comparative study of Lochtayside and Assynt - Vols 1, 2, 3 by Alexander Morrison, 1985

 

On the east side of the ravine is an ancient stone circle, Machuim.  First described in Thomas Pennant's A Tour in Scotland (1772), the local writer William A. Gillies’s In Famed Breadalbane (1938) said that "a recent examination of the ground around the circle...suggests that at one time there was an outer circle of stones concentric with the existing one.  Most of the stones were removed in order to make more of the field available for cultivation, but there are still large stones buried within a few inches of the surface."  J. McDiarmid wrote in 1910 in his Folklore of Breadalbane of a man from the nearby village of Killin who, on passing the stone circle heard haunting 'fairy' music.  He then entered into the circle. When he left he was 'presented' with a strong, fast, white horse.

 

The Lady of Lawers

Lawers was sited at the mouth of its eponymous Burn.  The castle of the lairds of Lawers was probably built close to the water's edge on the west bank. It was destroyed in 1645 and replaced by a less pretentious building that was occupied by the tenants of the farm of Milton of Lawers down to the latter part of last century.  The two storied house, the ruins of which are still visible, was reputed to be Tigh Ban-tigheaona Larbhuir, the House of the Lady of Lawers, who was said to have been a Stewart of Appin, and the wife of one of the lairds of Lawers.  The Lady was evidently a woman gifted with a wonderful measure of wisdom and shrewdness.  Among the predictions attributed to her is one connected with the building of the church, which was probably built by Sir James Campbell, the sixth laird. When the church was nearing completion, she said that the ridging-stones would never be placed on the roof.  The builders brought stones for the ridge from Kenmore by boat, and dumped them on the shore, saying:  “We shall prove the Lady to be a liar."  That night, however, a terrific storm raged along Loch Tay and the stones were swept into the depths.  Subsequently, the ridge of the church was covered with some other material.

 

Several of the Lady's sayings predicted changes in the social and economic conditions of the district.  A prophecy about fire-coaches yet to be seen crossing Druimuachder Pass was accepted as foretelling the coming of the Highland Railway over Drumochter. She foresaw a period when the population would greatly increase and the land be intensively cultivated: “there will be a mill on every stream and a plough in every field, and the two sides of Loch Tay will become a kail garden”.  This prophecy would appear to have come true by the end of the 18th Century, when there were fourteen mills along the lochside; on the south side alone there were nearly two hundred ploughs between Auchmore and Taymouth.

 

On living standards in Breadalbane

The reasons for this abundance are not immediately obvious, since the land could barely support its residents.  Historically, cultivation was on the runrig system, under the old in-field and out-field arrangement. On the poor upland soils, this antiquated arrangement gave the Highlanders a marginal existence.  The minister of Fortingal parish* found it hard to believe that they could exist on so little:  “They bled their cows several times in the year, boiled the blood, eat a little of it like bread, and a most lasting meal it was.”  The Earls of Breadalbane tried to relieve the pressure on the over-burdened land by building roads and bridges to open up the country and facilitate transport. They were instrumental in establishing flax processing as a major industry on Loch Tayside. They sent some farmers’ sons to England to learn the new methods of agriculture. On some of their lands, the process of replacing the old system began: new, compact farms were laid out; rotation of crops was established and winter feeds were improved.  Their “wise plans” ushered in a period of stability and relative prosperity so that, according to the minister of Killin*, the people were “in general, rather in easy than affluent circumstances” by the end of the 18th Century.  

 

This was not exactly the experience of Robert Heron writing of his 1793 Observations Made in a Journey through the Western Counties of Scotland.  On the banks of the River Tummel, he found refreshment in a house that “exhibited a scene of nastiness and simplicity which convinced me that the primitive manners of my country were not everywhere lost”.  There were also mixed opinions among the clerical authors of the Statistical Reports* concerning the standards of living of their parishioners - some despaired of their poverty, while others thought they were doing rather well.  The minister of Kenmore* recorded a population increase of 12% in the 45 years since Webster’s census return of 1755. Certainly, smallpox inoculations would have helped to reduce the death rate from that terrible disease. And, as potatoes grew to be the staple diet, people’s health and their survival rates would have improved.  Furthermore, the consolidation of farms being experienced elsewhere does not appear to have started in Kenmore until much later:  “The old system of rotation,” wrote the minister, “namely the infield land with oats and bear alternately and the outfield with oats and ley is in general continued …[and]… although it is certain that the noble proprietor might increase his rent roll considerably by enlarging the possessions and lessening the number of tenants, yet, knowing their attachment to the country, he allows them to remain in the abodes of their forefathers”.  Unfortunately, this meant that, “In these places, the tenants in general have but very small possessions, several of them being crowded together in the same farm”.  Even in the 1840s, the incumbent observed that “farm buildings, in general, are in an indifferent state” because few leases were granted and holdings remained subdivided.

By contrast, in neighbouring Rannoch, the old ‘Stake and Rise’ houses (one had to enter on all fours and, once inside, would be unable to stand upright) had been replaced by “comfortable houses built of stone”.  “People”, stated the minister of Fortingal*, writing about the 1750s, “were starving.” Yet, 50 years later, although rents had tripled, “the people have fulness of bread”.  In Killin, there was some depopulation, “by the union of farms and the number of sheep introduced …. and it must be admitted that, owing to these causes, the number of people has decreased considerably in the higher parts … but it has increased in the lower parts … particularly in the village of Killin.

So the apparent discrepancies in the ministerial accounts* of the day were simply matters of emphasis.  For example, depopulation, when “swarms leave the country every year”, was certainly taking place, but it was chiefly in the remote hill areas.  One of the reasons was the increased stocking of farms with sheep, which required only a few shepherds to manage.  Pushed off their farms, the landless refugees ended up in the villages and found work in service, as workers in the flax industry or as masons, joiners, shoemakers, smiths, farriers and other craftsmen.  And some, of course, emigrated to the new lands overseas.

 

The Cheviot comes to Loch Tay

The Lady of Lawers also foretold that the jaws of the sheep would drive the plough out of the ground, that many holdings would become one holding and that the homesteads on Loch Tayside would be so far apart that a cock would not be able to hear his neighbour crow. This prophecy predicted the evictions that took place on Loch Tayside during the 1830s, when people were cleared from the land in order to establish large sheep runs. As John Campbell of Lochend wrote, "the sides of Loch Tay in general were never intended by nature for the plough, and if the fertile, level lands in the better climate of England were thought to be more profitable under grass than under the plough, what could be expected from cultivation of the steep, broken patches of land on Lochtayside, however good the quality might be, so far north, so high above the sea and so frequently deluged with rain?" There had been attempts to introduce the Cheviot sheep to Breadalbane farms in the 18th Century but they were not well received by the locals. However, in 1834, the Second Marquis allowed his factor, James Wyllie, to evict families and to populate his farms with Cheviots.  By 1838, fourteen families had been removed forcibly from Rhynachuilig, twelve from Edramchie, thirteen from Kiltyrie, nine from Cloichran, and nineteen from the farm of Acharn, all on the lochside.  

There is no mention of Lawers or Cuiltrannich in this dismal roll call and, to judge from the numbers crammed into the longhouses at the time of the 1841 Census, they escaped the terror.  The evictions were carried out with ruthless severity.  No sooner were the people turned out of their homes than the thatch was set on fire to prevent them from returning.  A man who was very active as an agent in carrying out the dastardly work was himself evicted, and forced to emigrate.  As he was leaving the township someone asked him: "Is there no more dirty work to be done in Breadalbane when they are sending you away?"  After a decade, the land was striking in its emptiness. Of the 3500 inhabitants once living on Loch Tayside, only one hundred were left by 1850.  That year the Second Marquis tried to raise a Fencible Regiment, as his father had successfully done in the 18th Century. He found no recruits.  An old man of Loch Tayside is reputed to have growled at him to "Put your red coats on the backs of the sheep that have replaced the men!"  

Although the evictions came to an end, depopulation continued, and the land gradually went out of cultivation. The old primitive houses built with dry-stone walls and thatched roofs decayed.  Young people left to go to the cities, in the case of the young Duncan McDougall, to Edinburgh to sell alcohol. The estate had no housing policy. Few tenants had security of tenure and there was no assurance that they would be compensated for any improvements that they made. The result was that holding was added to holding and farm to farm until there was not sufficient man power to work and manage the land. The country-side at present is reverting to the state of nature from which generations of industrious farmers reclaimed it by clearing away the brush-wood, gathering the stones, and erecting miles and miles of boundary walls. Fields that not long ago were under cultivation are now covered with briars, thorns, bracken, and scrub. Thus have the Lady of Lawers’ predictions been fulfilled to the letter.

 

Some of her other prophecies refer to the old church of Lawers, now a ruin beside her house.  A stone over the doorway of this church bears the date 1669, which would suggest that she lived around the middle of the seventeenth century. She is buried under the gateway of the old, walled graveyard by the loch.  Between this burial ground and the church lie the remains of the old village of Lawers, with the ruins of the mill and mill race visible.  Well above the water, on the road between Kenmore and Killin are a group of buildings - the old-established Ben Lawers Hotel, the School and the Free Church, which was formerly the Church of Scotland Mission. 

 

*Statistical Accounts for Scotland 1791-99 and 1834-55